The Menendez Evidence Revisited

Beverly Hills, 1989. Jose and Kitty Menendez are shot to death in their own living room. Their sons Lyle and Erik claim a home invasion. Years later, the truth comes out — and the world has been arguing about it ever since.

In this episode of Murder, Mystery & Makeup, host Bailey Sarian blends true crime storytelling with her signature makeup-look format, walking through the Menendez case and the evidence that's resurfaced in the wake of renewed public interest. It's a perfect companion piece if you've already watched Netflix's documentary and want more context on the family dynamics, the trials, and the abuse allegations that shaped the defense.

The brothers' case has been back in the headlines — their bid for resentencing and parole consideration has kept the story very much alive, decades after the murders. New generations are discovering the case through documentaries and social media, and the questions about what really happened in that house, and what justice should look like now, are far from settled.

Press play tonight and listen on Spotify for the full breakdown.